In the 2nd UPR process, Malaysian government accepted 113 recommendations in full, from a total of 232 recommendations submitted to Malaysia from various member states in the UPR.
The Coalition of Malaysian NGOs in the UPR Process (COMANGO) was formed by civil society organisations in 2008 to engage in the Universal Periodic Review (UPR) of the United Nations.
Recommendation accepted in Full
Recommendations accepted in Part and in Principle
From the total of 150 recommendations accepted, 15 recommendations are accepted in part, and 22 are accepted in principle.
Recommendations noted by Malaysia
82 recommendations from peer delegates are noted from a total of 232 recommendations. This means, Malaysia only accepted 64.66% of recommendations, may it be full, partial or in principle.
Level 1 to level 3 of the recommendations received were non-measurable which prompts general actions emphasising continuity and a mere request to consider change
Level 4 and 5 are those which require specific actions with words such as “ensure, take measures, implement or ratify”
Referring to the categories of measurability determined and used by UPR Info, COMANGO identified a total of 64 measurable recommendations of which they were able to assess. These recommendations are divided into Level 1 to 5, depending on the actions needed.
COMANGO's report focuses on three aspects of implementation:
- The existence (or lack) of substantive law reform or new policies
- Practices on the ground
- Agencies responsible for implementing the recommendations
“[i]t is primarily the obligation of States to protect those who cooperate with the United Nations, its representatives and mechanisms in the field of human rights and to ensure that they may do so safely and without hindrance.”Ban Ki MoonFormer United Nations Secretary General
“Much more attention and action is needed on human rights in Malaysia.”Datuk Ho May YongMinistry of Foreign Affairs, Malaysia
“We have underscored that the relationship with all stakeholders should not be limited to mere consultation. We have not only invited but have stated many times that the government alone cannot deliver. The participation of non-state actors, particularly the NGOs and the private sector is imperative.”Datuk Haji Abdul Rahman DahlanMinister in the Prime Minister's Office (Economic Planning Unit), during Malaysia's High Level Political Forum National Voluntary Review, 2017
“I am humble enough to admit that the era of the ‘government knows all’ is over.”Datuk Seri Najib Tun RazakPrime Minister of Malaysia